How much does it cost to open a thrift store?

A thrift store typically costs $20,000 to $120,000 to open. The major advantage over other retail businesses is low inventory cost, since much of your stock comes from donations, estate sales, and bulk purchases at pennies on the dollar. Your biggest expense will be the commercial lease and store fixtures.

How do thrift stores get their inventory?

Thrift stores source inventory through community donations (free), estate sale purchases ($500-$5,000 per sale), storage unit auctions, bulk clothing bales from textile recyclers ($0.50-$2 per pound), and consignment arrangements. Building a reliable donation pipeline through community partnerships and donation drives is the key to keeping inventory costs near zero.

Are thrift stores profitable?

Thrift stores can be highly profitable because inventory costs are extremely low, often 10-20% of retail price versus 50-60% for traditional retail. A well-run thrift store with donated inventory can achieve gross margins of 80-90%. The challenge is volume, as you need consistent foot traffic and a large enough store to display sufficient inventory.

Thrift Store Startup Cost Comparison

Carmel, IN vs New York, NY

Carmel, IN

$21,000 - $115,000

COL Index: 106.5

New York, NY

$40,000 - $219,000

COL Index: 187.2

Detailed Cost Comparison

Expense	Carmel, IN	New York, NY	Difference
Business Registration & Permits	$1,400 - $5,100	$5,300 - $17,100	-71%
Commercial Lease (First + Last + Security)	$5,900 - $39,100	$15,700 - $104,300	-63%
Initial Inventory Sourcing	$2,000 - $10,000	$2,000 - $10,000	Same
Store Build-Out & Fixtures	$3,100 - $25,500	$4,400 - $36,300	-30%
POS System & Pricing Tools	$800 - $4,000	$800 - $4,000	Same
Business Insurance (Annual)	$1,200 - $4,000	$1,200 - $4,000	Same
Marketing & Community Outreach	$1,000 - $6,000	$1,000 - $6,000	Same
Working Capital (3 Months)	$5,300 - $21,300	$9,400 - $37,400	-43%
Total Estimated Cost	$21,000 - $115,000	$40,000 - $219,000	-47%

Local Market Factors

Factor	Carmel	New York
Cost of Living Index	106.5	187.2
Commercial Rent ($/sqft/yr)	$18 - $42	$40 - $120
Labor Rate Index	1.02	1.45
Sales Tax	7%	8.875%
Minimum Wage	$7.25/hr	$16.00/hr
LLC Filing Fee	$95	$200

View Full Details

Ready to Start Your Thrift Store?

Start your Thrift Store LLC in — free registered agent for 1 year.

Form Your LLC for $0 + State Fee →

Trusted by 500,000+ businesses · Excellent rating on Trustpilot